They lived and died by the tens of thousands for their faith, yet few of us really know who the Huguenots were. Were it not for the research I conducted for my novel, The Space Between Words, they’d be little more to me than interesting footnotes in the annals of Christian history.
Yet in startling ways, there are parallels between the Huguenots and modern day Americans—right down to the mistakes we’re repeating for similar reasons.
They lived in the 16th , 17th and 18th centuries, followers of Martin Luther who were exterminated for rejecting the control of the Catholic Church and embracing a theology that prized relationship with God. At a time when political clout depended on religious dominance, their departure from state mandated theology was seen as a mutiny—its perpetrators too dangerous to be allowed to speak.
By some accounts, more than 60,000 Huguenots lost their lives to merciless soldiers called dragoons, charged by French kings and loyal noblemen with exterminating the “vermin” whose faith spelled their extinction.
Faced with forced conversion, imprisonment, torture and death, thousands of these fledgling Protestants fled to more welcoming places, while a majority stayed behind to face unimaginable horrors.
Some chose to fight back. It is those who give me pause today.
The story of those counter-punching Huguenots is not a noble one. It traces the moral decline of believers whose rebellion was fueled by fear—not faith—and enforced by the ungodliest of measures.
Fear is a destructive force. In its combative form, it is dehumanizing too. Beyond the persecution decimating their people, some members of Huguenot nobility also feared losing their power—the leverage and relevance that defined them in their culture. They feared being stripped of their influence and freedoms.
To combat those losses, they chose to remain in France and turned to mercenaries who would fight for their rights—warriors who identified as Huguenots, but were really prize-fighters known for employing the same inhumane tactics the king was inflicting on the protestant community.
There’s no doubt that they fought well—they figure as heroes of major battles. There’s also no doubt that they committed atrocities in the name of protecting the protestant faith. Neither children nor women were spared from the barbaric assaults they plotted and led.
With hindsight we might wonder how the Huguenots fell to such depths. How could so many Christ-believing and God-fearing Protestants align themselves with savages known for methods that stood in abject contradiction to the faith they were protecting? The answer is simple—it’s fear.
- Fear of losing power.
- Fear of losing influence.
- Fear of becoming irrelevant in politics and culture.
Centuries have passed, but not much has changed.
I see Christians today enlisting modern mercenaries—high profile combatants professing to fight for the values and welfare of believers, but whose character and tactics are no different from their adversaries’. It’s the same fear that drove the Huguenots that motivates us now. Fear of losing power. Fear of losing influence. Fear of becoming irrelevant in politics and culture.
Mind you, it isn’t persecution that pushes us to our extremes, not if we honestly compare our plight to that of the Huguenots. We can worship freely. We can speak of our faith. We can own Bibles and attend Christian summer camps. We can wear our “God is love” t-shirts or wave our “God hates fags” flags (shame on us) without the threat of dismemberment and death. Is society changing? Yes. Is it diversifying in ethnicity and faith? Absolutely. The United States has become increasingly pluralistic—but ask the Huguenots if sharing the public square with other religions amounts to the kind of suffering they endured.
Yet despite the freedoms we enjoy, there is a movement in the American church to align itself with today’s mercenaries in order to preserve what fear-mongers tell us we’re losing.
If you’ve stood on the sidelines as I have, watching the shift from moral authority to political dominance, you too might feel a grief akin to heartbreak.
It’s made of disappointment—because so many spiritual leaders have contorted their definition of right and wrong to align themselves with mercenaries who boast of their flaws, but vow to employ enough dirty tactics to preserve the Church’s sense of security.
It’s made of embarrassment—because those mercenaries have become the most visible representatives of a faith that should be founded on acceptance, grace, mercy, love, redemption, self-sacrifice and inclusion. On immersive influence, not political clout.
It’s made of pessimism—because I fear the hateful rhetoric, hurtful methods and unChristian attitudes employed by God’s people will indelibly taint his image and our legacy.
The church’s unholy alliance with modern day mercenaries will not be measured in greater freedoms and heightened respect. I fear it will instead be quantified in losses—loss of authority, loss of integrity, loss of identity. Or more tragically yet, the loss of an untold number of souls, onlookers who might have been teetering on the verge of believing, but found their curiosity soured by the unscrupulous methods of spiritual leaders reaching for unbiblical clout.
There are days like today when my integrity feels bruised. Wearied by the calls for unholy compromise. Wounded by the conflation of politics and faith. Disheartened by assertions that God’s agenda requires governmental control.
When the perpetual duel between my fight and flight instincts depletes my emotional energy, I go back to the words I scribbled into the margins of a Sunday-morning bulletin several weeks ago:
God calls me to integrity—to honor and kindness and compassionate truth.
He calls me to a loving and inspiring influence.
Not to a political party.
Not to cultural power or social relevance.
Jesus lived by that call every day of his life. And I want to be like him.
So when the cacophony of defamation “in the name of God” becomes overwhelming, I’m comforted by the Huguenots’ story, which didn’t end with the dragonades that killed so many of them. The Protestant church that found its inception in Luther, then Calvin, that endured unimaginable persecution, then survived decimation and mass evacuation—it lives on today.
And not because of its mercenaries. Because of the fearless faithful who would not surrender and would not compromise.
We cannot fight wrong with wrong. Not even for faith. Especially not for faith.
I see Christ in those who chose death or exile over freedom and power. Just as I see him in Corrie Ten Boom’s hope-filled suffering and Jim Elliott’s uncompromising obedience. I see Christ today in those who choose conversation over debate, persuasion over power. Who seek meaningful influence by legitimate and honorable means. Who will not let their integrity be tarnished or God’s image be distorted by:
- Fear of losing power.
- Fear of losing influence.
- Fear of becoming irrelevant in politics and culture.
God’s Kingdom on Earth cannot be derailed by the politics of men. And it will not be achieved by empowering the mercenaries who claim to fight battles he has already won to protect a faith that cannot be destroyed.
Huguenot prize fighters may have won some battles, centuries ago, but they stand in hindsight as affronts to Jesus’ heart and God’s commands—a shameful stain on our collective history.
Despite the claims of modern Evangelical leaders elevating and endorsing blatantly immoral flag-bearers, the Kingdom God speaks of must begin with le commun des mortels—with the flawed but willing common man. With me. With a commitment to act justly and love mercy in the small but still significant contexts in which I live. With a willingness to shun all wrongs, strategic as they may be, and to embrace instead a more vulnerable good, with the unwavering certainty that in his power and in his time, the Kingdom he promised will finally come.
“He [the devil] always sends errors into the world in pairs—pairs of
opposites. And he always encourages us to spend a lot of time thinking
which is the worse. You see why, of course. He relies on your extra
dislike of the one error to draw you gradually into the opposite one.
But do not let us be fooled. We have to keep our eyes on the goal and
go straight through between both errors. We have no other concern
than that with either of them.”
- Contribute your thoughts in the comments section below
- Use the social media links to Like and Share this article
- To subscribe, email email@example.com and write “subscribe” in the subject line
- Pick up Of Stillness and Storm (my novel about a missionary calling gone awry) on Amazon
I love this. You have summed up so beautifully what has been in my heart.
Good words Michele.
Thank you for this. For those of us who believe God is Sovereign to act in fear and desperation is a repudiation of our faith. If God is in it nothing formed against us will stand. If He isn’t in it we are wasting our time fighting. He emphatically doesn’t need us and our pathetic swords to change the world.
Nicely done, Michèle. My personal in-depth study of Isaiah has underlined for me the point you make at the end — God’s kingdom is enduring and God’s plans WILL NOT FAIL and CANNOT BE THWARTED. By anyone. The broken world that we live in needs believers to be the hands and feet of Jesus, yes — a thousand times yes. But God’s kingdom does NOT need believers comprising Christ-like character and values to “save the world”. Au contraire!! More than ever before we need to be sticking out like sore thumbs in a society gone horribly wrong! May God give us the strength and perseverance and humility and grace we need to joyfully and obediently follow His ways!! May God revive His church in America and around the world.
Really powerful blog Michelle.
I, like millions of non-Americans, are standing at the moment in disbelief at the deteriorating saga of what (so many) people of the US are doing to their country. It’s almost like watching a disaster movie scenario. And as you say — so many are so-called Christians. Looking in from outside, and based on knowing numbers of US citizens in international settings, I blame the widespread ignorance about the world outside their American bubble, that leaves them with a false idea of reality — combined with the lack of understanding of what Jesus taught, which you mention. The latter is desperately sad; combined with the former – it’s a dangerous mix.
Anyway – just wanted to say that I think this is the best blog I’ve read in a long time.
Very thoughtful article, thank you. Politics with integrity is not politics by manipulation. But even if not actively involved in politics there still remains the question of how to vote. We advocate for people of integrity but often don’t feel like those are the candidates offered in the end.
Some of my ancestors were Huguenots who came to Staten Island and eventually made their way to central Pennsylvania where the family lives now.